I have some real treats for you today with this beautiful and delicious collection of Homemade Gluten-Free Pop Tart Recipes! Or toaster pastries if you prefer.
Just in time for National Pop Tart Day today, November 19! Store-bought Pop Tarts, which of course are not gluten free, were first launched by Kellogg’s on November 19, 1964.
Most of you reading may be totally focused on Thanksgiving next week—understandably so—but I wanted to have these recipes here on gfe for you for the future. Homemade pop tarts or one of the other pop tart themed recipes here (pop tart cookies and pop tart bars!) may be just perfect for enjoying during the Christmas holiday season. Even as something very special to enjoy on Christmas morning perhaps!
Oh, the perfectly toasted crusty edges and the warm flavorful fillings that together are just so wonderful!
I will admit that I was a fan of Pop Tarts back in the day. The brown sugar cinnamon ones were my favorite. Although I did occasionally enjoy a chocolate one now and then. To be honest, they always disappointed me. There was only a single chocolate flavor at the time, that I recall anyway, and they were not nearly as good as the brown sugar cinnamon flavored ones. There are many, many more flavors of chocolate Pop Tarts—and Pop Tarts in general—today than there were before I went gluten free.
But I can absolutely guarantee that these homemade gluten-free versions are superior to the ready-made ones we all may have eaten at one time. So let’s get to it! Here are some incredible homemade gluten-free pop tart recipes from the amazing community resources we always appreciate!
Homemade Gluten-Free Pop Tart Recipes
~ Gluten-Free Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies from All Day I Dream About Food ~ gluten free, grain free, sugar free, low carb, keto

Gluten-Free Keto Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies from All Day I Dream About Food
~ Gluten-Free Brown Sugar Pop Tarts from Sarah Bakes Gluten Free ~ gluten free, dairy free, egg free, vegetarian, vegan (Note: If using the oat milk option, please ensure that it is certified gluten free and made from purity protocol oats.)

Gluten-Free and Vegan Brown Sugar Pop Tarts from Sarah Bakes Gluten Free
~ Gluten-Free Dairy-Free Egg-Free Pop Tarts from Adventures of a Gluten-Free Mom ~ gluten free, dairy free, egg free, vegetarian, with vegan options (Can you tell Heidi has an obsession with goldfish?! Some of you may remember when she created her own gluten-free goldfish crackers long, long before there were gluten-free goldfish crackers to buy.)

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Adventures of a Gluten-Free Mom
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tart Bars from All Day I Dream About Food ~ gluten free, grain free, sugar free, low carb, keto

Gluten-Free Keto Pop Tart Bars from All Day I Deram About Food
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts (Cherry, Raspberry, or Strawberry) from Sarah Bakes Gluten Free ~ gluten free, dairy free, egg free, vegetarian, vegan

Gluten-Free and Vegan Pop Tarts from Sarah Bakes Gluten Free
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts (Heart Shaped) from Allergy Free Alaska ~ gluten free, egg free, vegetarian, with dairy-free, vegan options

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts (Heart Shaped) from Allergy Free Alaska
~ Gluten-Free Homemade Toaster Pastries from GF Jules ~ gluten free, egg free, vegetarian, with dairy-free, vegan option (Jules even shows you how to make adorable holiday-themed toaster pastries!)

Gluten-Free Toaster Pastries (aka Homemade Pop Tarts) from GF Jules

Halloween-Themed Gluten-Free Toaster Pastries (aka Homemade Pop Tarts) from GF Jules
~ Gluten-Free Hot Chocolate Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk ~ gluten free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free Hot Chocolate Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk
~ Gluten-Free Fruit Pop Tarts from Janice Amee ~ gluten free, vegetarian, with dairy-free, egg-free, vegan options

Gluten-Free Fruit Pop Tarts from Janice Aimee
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Fearless Dining ~ gluten free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Fearless Dining
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Let Them Eat Gluten-Free Cake ~ gluten free, vegetarian (Kim gives you flavor choices.)

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Let Them Eat Gluten-Free Cake
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Mama Knows Gluten Free ~ gluten free, vegetarian, with dairy-free option

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from Mama Knows Gluten Free
~ Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from The Nomadic Fitzpatricks ~ gluten free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from The Nomadic Fitzpatricks
~ Gluten-Free Raspberry-Glazed Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk ~ gluten free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free Raspberry-Glazed Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk
~ Gluten-Free S’mores Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk ~ gluten free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free S’mores Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk
~ Gluten-Free Strawberry Pop Tarts from Strength and Sunshine ~ gluten free, dairy free, egg free, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan

Homemade Gluten-Free Strawberry Pop Tarts from Strength and Sunshine
~ Gluten-Free Triple Chocolate Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk ~ gluten free, egg free, vegetarian

Gluten-Free Triple Chocolate Pop Tarts from The Loopy Whisk
~ Paleo Pop Tarts (AIP/Nut Free/Egg Free) from Predominantly Paleo ~ gluten free, grain free, dairy free, egg free, paleo

Gluten-Free and Paleo Pop Tarts from Predominantly Paleo
~ Paleo Raspberry Pop Tarts from A Girl Worth Saving ~ gluten free, grain free, dairy free, egg free, refined sugar free, paleo

Gluten-Free Pop Tarts from A Girl Worth Saving
~ Vegan Pop Tarts from Chocolate-Covered Katie ~ gluten free (you must use the gluten-free option cited in the post above the recipe), dairy free, egg free, vegetarian, vegan, with sugar-free option

Vegan Pop Tarts from Chocolate-Covered Katie
Originally published November 18, 2026.

Leave a Reply